Logo primary
Logo secondary
Thomas Fischbacher 's Profile
Thomas Fischbacher
Details
Joined:
26/01/2011
Last Updated:
04/03/2011
Location:
Southampton, Hampshire, United Kingdom
Climate Zone:
Cool Temperate
Gender:
Male





My Projects

(projects i'm involved in)


Projects

(projects i'm following)

Zaytuna Farm, The home of the permaculture Research Institute
Followers
Aranya Austin Chris McLeod Frank  Wolf Hannes Dettmann Mustafa Fatih Bakir
Following
Albert Bates Chris Evans Darren J.  Doherty Geoff Lawton

Back to Thomas Fischbacher's profile

Anomalies in Science

Posted by Thomas Fischbacher about 13 years ago

Is economics as it is done these days actually a science?

When preparing my "Mathematics for Complex Systems" lecture (pretty much all I do during semester 2 of the academic year is teaching), I came across something curious - striking evidene that quite famous people in the academic profession of economics are not actually using mathematics to adequately model processes, but instead are systematically abusing mathematics to bamboozle their audience (or at least the less maths-savvy members among them).

The actual discussion is somewhat technical, it involves a simple non-linear system (perhaps the simplest one one can write down) known as the "logistic map". If one actually happens to know a little bit about its properties (to the level it would be covered in an introductory lecture, such as mine), it becomes quite evident how Yale professor of economics William Nordhaus tries to frame it in a way that is mathematically wrong in order to debunk the Meadows "Limits to Growth" study.

Science constantly is under seige from pseudo-scientific ideologies that try to sneak into the ivory tower in order to benefit from some sort of perceived elevated status of disciplines that are recognized as science (think Lyssenkoism, say). Alas, as it seems, occasionally, some such ideologies succeed, and there is considerable evidence that something very much like that might have happened with the "science" of economics.

My lecture notes can be found at http://www.soton.ac.uk/~doctom/teaching/soton/modules/SESG6029/current/generated/08-L.pdf - the relevant bits for this WPN item are pages 16, 17, and 26-32.

Comments (2)

You must be logged in to comment.

Øyvind Holmstad
Øyvind Holmstad : Just like with architecture! (modernism)
Posted almost 13 years ago

Report Øyvind Holmstad on Anomalies in Science

Reason:

or cancel

Øyvind Holmstad
Øyvind Holmstad : Just like with architecture! (modernism)
Posted almost 13 years ago

Report Øyvind Holmstad on Anomalies in Science

Reason:

or cancel

My Permaculture Qualifications
Verified
course
Type: Permaculture Design Certificate (PDC) course
Teacher: Chris Evans
Location: Dorset, UK
Date: Jan 2007

Report Thomas Fischbacher

Reason:

or cancel

Hide Thomas Fischbacher

Reason:

or cancel

Hide Anomalies in Science

Reason:

or cancel

Report Anomalies in Science

Reason:

or cancel