Logo primary
Logo secondary

Back to Frank Gapinski's profile

Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Posted by Frank Gapinski about 13 years ago

A number of Permaculture people don't like Aquaponics. They reckon if its not grown in soil then it musn't be very good. I'm not one of them.

Just so you know, we make and sell DVDs on Aquaponics with Aquaponics guru Murray Hallam. But this isnt a sales pitch. I don't care if you buy one of our DVDs or not. The truth is a couple of years ago I got interested in Aquaponics and wanted to know more. I was never very good at keeping fish. Well I did keep a goldfish in a bowl for almost a year that lived in very dirty water. One day I had an idea to change its water - and it promptly died. Thats another story. So I was your average person with really no interest in keeping fish in the backyard.

But I was interested in growing vegetables with them.

Our backyard is right next to the beach. We live on a sand dune. The soil is very, very white. A few years ago sand mining companies wanted to mine it. Its first class silica sand. Good for making computer parts. Bad for making vegetables. Yeah, we tried putting manure and chicken poo on our vegetable patch and it does work - for a while. But eventually the nutrients wash away. Goodbye soil fertility. Hello sad looking vegetables.

 

Fast forward to Yandina Permaculure Gardens a year later. Guest speaker is Mr Murray Hallam who makes fibreglass kit troughs for Aquaponics. I met him after his talk and we got on like a house on fire. He's a great bloke. When my wife Jane and I saw his aquaponics garden - we were hooked. He had cabbages and strawberrys growing like gangbusters! He had a mighty looking pawpaw tree reaching into the top of his greenhouse - loaded with fruit. Was he using chemicals? Nope! He had all sorts of herbs cascading down around his growbeds. Nothing looked like it was struggling. The plants looked terrific.

I wanted what he had. As we drove home I convinced Jane why it was a good idea. Firstly - no bending and no digging. No weeding. No bad backs. Everything at waist level. Secondly No Soil! That might scare you - but I thought it was a terrific idea. No dirt under your fingernails and lets face it - all those red coloured clay balls? Is that too ridiculous?

When I said to Murray "How do you plant your veges in these red balls? He showed me. "First wash away all the dirt." Nothing adheres to the plant roots! This is too much I thought. Looks like Hydroponics. Well it is - kind of. Next thing he just plunged the seedling straight into the clay beads. It was a hot summers day and I thought to myself "These plants will be dead by tomorrow."  Yes they did keel over in the hot sun and looked exhausted. Next morning however the plants were standing up straight and looking cheerful. What happend?

Bacteria. Billions of "soil" bacteria were feeding the plant roots the fish poop. They were breaking down the fish waste into minerals. Since we got into Aquaponics we have harvested around 50 Jade Perch around 400 grams. Not big fish but Aquaponics is not about big game hunting. Its about balance. Keeping the right ratio of fish mass to grow bed size. Too many fish and you will struggle to keep the water flow back to the fish clean. Too little fish and the plants wont have enough nutrients.

What about plant nutrients? How sustainable is it? Do fish pellets which are grown from depleted sea reserves of ocean catch the right way to go? Its a valid question and one that we are looking at eliminating eventually. We know Jade Perch will eat green vegetables. The stuff we grow - we feed back to them. They love lettuce. We grow compost worms in a seperate bath tub system and they will devour the worms with glee. You can also grow black soldier fly larvae and the the larvae can be frozen for use over winter. Duckweed is another good source of protein that fish love to eat. We have grown all this and its not hard to do. In the back of my mind the question of how nutritionally dense is the food grown in Aquaponics? Is it deficient in certain minerals not found in fish pellets? Well the vegetables grown look perfect to my untrained eye. We have grown tasteless tomatoes and we have grown sweet full flavoured tomatoes just the way you imagine the perfect tomato to be in aquaponics. It all depend on the variety of the produce you choose. But to be on the safe side - because we don't have all the facts - I like to give our aquaponics system a good slurp of worm juice.Remember it is all about cycling nutrients through the bacteria and back through the worms and back through the plants and back into your body and so on.

There are many mineral elements in worm juice and its also harmless to fish.

Its now our second year with Aquaponics. The system does mature over time and I believe that as a system matures various heirachies of microorganisms colonise the system and enrich the system. We have grown heaps of vegetables. So is Aquaponics the Answer? It wont save the planet. People will still require a high carbohydrate diet in corn or wheat or rice, but for a small urban garden space and we have a small courtyard system - you really can't beat it for the sheer volume of fish and vegetables it will produce continually for many years. Today we took delivery of 50 very small Jade Perch fingerlings that went into the system. The cycle continues...

Comments (20)

You must be logged in to comment.

Mark Brown
Mark Brown : Kool - I want a DVD!!
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Mark Brown on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Kalinya  Farm
Kalinya Farm : Great post. Thankyou. I bought the dvd and it is very good.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Kalinya Farm on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Kirsten Bradley
Kirsten Bradley : we just finished making an aquaponics system for a primary school in Sydney and it totally rocks. Looking forward to installing one at Milkwood Farm in the spring.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Kirsten Bradley on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Frank Gapinski
Frank Gapinski : Good one Kirsten.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Frank Gapinski on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Paul Young
Paul Young : wow, i actually watched one of your aquaponics dvds yesterday. other than financial outlay for the infrastructure, i cant fault aquaponics. i look forward to playing with it in the future (and eating lots of fish, yum).
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Paul Young on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Floyd C. Constable
Floyd C. Constable : Really great post. I helped build the system in Sydney that Kirsten mentioned, and I'm hooked.

Paul, as far infrastructure goes, sure there is an unavoidable outlay (pump, grow medium etc) , but many of the required bits and pieces (grow beds, ponds etc) can be made using recycled and home made stuff. Great fun!
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Floyd C. Constable on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Paul Young
Paul Young : thanks floyd. i did some poking around and murray hallams diy kit is $200! even i can afford that. as i am in a rental and probably going to have to move next year, i wont be puting anything together just yet but i am certainly going to be looking to collect suitable tanks and grow beds as they come about.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Paul Young on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Frank Gapinski
Frank Gapinski : Go on Ebay and search for IBC tanks. Buy 3 and get Murray's DIY Aquaponics DVD out in a few weeks as it has all the PDF and 2 hour video instruction included to build a 1000 litre 3 bed IBC DIY Aquaponics system for a few hundred bucks in outlay. Cost is mainly for the large tanks. New pump is about $80. Hose and pipe Fittings you can scrounge etc...
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Frank Gapinski on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Paul Young
Paul Young : thanks, theres a guy selling good looking ibc's near me for $100. eagerly awaiting the dvd frank.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Paul Young on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

jordan lowery
jordan lowery : aquaponics systems have a lot of potential, specially when you get into growing more than just fish and food. i have seen people do it absolutely wrong though and end up with horrible plants and fish.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report jordan lowery on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Frank Gapinski
Frank Gapinski : The DVD is completed and it will be out in about two weeks. I'm sure Geoff Lawton's shop will have some to sell as well. Here is a teaser we put together on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPxL-fLgWkM Some epic music for an epic little food production system.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Frank Gapinski on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Chad Perrault
Chad Perrault : Great stuff, I've got my window farm hooked up to a very large fish tank as a reservoir. Now I'm just looking to buy some tilapia.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Chad Perrault on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Chief Phillip 'Cloudpiler' Landis
Chief Phillip 'Cloudpiler' Landis : With the U.S. just passing the bogus Food Safety Act, we are really looking at Federal control of the food supply. Home food production and aquaponics for protein are high on our priority list for this year.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Chief Phillip 'Cloudpiler' Landis on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Paul Young
Paul Young : there is a guy in brissy selling (once used no chemicals)ibc's for $100 at brookfield. im going to pick up a BLACK one today! nice and dark for my yummy fishies. phone chris 0412089556 before i buy them all, my wife will eat me.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Paul Young on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Paul Young
Paul Young : $120.. the ad said $100. tsk tsk.
Posted about 13 years ago

Report Paul Young on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Report on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Daisy Blare
Daisy Blare : Even though it was a long time ago, I also want to add my opinion that aquaculture is the future.
Posted almost 2 years ago

Report Daisy Blare on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Daryl Gana
Daryl Gana : credible login
Posted 11 months ago

Report Daryl Gana on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Kate Wilson
Kate Wilson : Our team of expert mechanics can come directly to you and provide a variety of preventive maintenance services such as oil changes, tire rotations, and brake inspections. Garden Grove Mobile Mechanic
Posted 4 months ago

Report Kate Wilson on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Lynda Mejia
Lynda Mejia : Relax and stay connected anywhere in your vacation home with Moving no contract broadband uk . This guide highlights the flexibility and convenience of their solutions, ensuring you have reliable connectivity no matter where you are. Explore Moving Internet's offerings for a stress-free and connected vacation home experience.
Posted 2 months ago

Report Lynda Mejia on Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

My Permaculture Qualifications
Pri verified
Permaculture Design Course
Type: Permaculture Design Certificate (PDC) course
Verifying teacher: Geoff Lawton
Other Teachers: Bill Mollison
Location: Melbourne
Date: Sep 2005

Report Frank Gapinski

Reason:

or cancel

Hide Frank Gapinski

Reason:

or cancel

Hide Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel

Report Is Aquaponics the Answer?

Reason:

or cancel